The Criterion Voyages (Spine #1212): SAINT OMER -- Alice Diop's Extraordinary Courtroom Drama Is Finally Available on Physical Media

Review by Sean Boelman

Recently, Criterion has been partnering with indie distributor extraordinaire NEON to release some of its films through the boutique label. The latest is Saint Omer, a criminally underseen courtroom drama that served as documentarian Alice Diop's narrative feature debut. This release is a welcome opportunity for fans to get their hands on a copy of the best movie of 2022.

Saint Omer follows a novelist who attends the trial of a woman accused of murdering her infant daughter, causing her to reflect on her own life and how the case resonates with her. Submitted by France for the Oscar for Best International Feature but unfortunately snubbed, Saint Omer holds up incredibly well.

Diop’s film stands out from most other courtroom dramas because of its documentary-like approach, which makes sense considering her background in nonfiction filmmaking. It is not the type of court movie with quick dialogue and chess-like legal tactics; Diop is much more interested in the intricacies of the story and their even deeper implications and contexts. 

The result is a movie that feels incredibly emotional, even by the genre's standards. Of course, there was no doubt that a movie about a mother accused of these crimes wouldn’t be a stirring watch, but the perspective through which Diop presents it makes the emotional elements all the more complex and impactful.

Diop also has some worthy and talented collaborators in actresses Guslagie Malanda and Kayije Kagame. Saint Omer rightfully served as a breakout for Malanda, whose tremendous performance as the woman on trial is as crushing as they come (she would later appear in The Beast alongside Lea Seydoux and George McKay). Yet, although Malanda’s performance is the more immediately forward, Kagame’s stands out on rewatch as especially potent in its quietness and mannerisms.

However, what stands out most about Saint Omer, upon revisiting it over a year later, is how tender it is with its themes. Although the story might seem somewhat straightforward on its surface, there are incredibly prescient undercurrents running through it, exploring themes like immigration, femininity, and misogyny. The script, written by Diop along with Amrita David and Marie N’Diaye, sticks with you in ways you would not expect.

In terms of bonus features, this edition of Saint Omer features some new interviews with director Alice Diop, making it a relatively bare release compared to most of the newer movies that enter the Criterion Collection. The 2K restoration is solid, but it is important to note that this is not being released in 4K — only Blu-Ray and DVD.

Ultimately, the Criterion of Saint Omer is worth picking up, if only to get the opportunity to own this incredible work of French cinema. Unlike most of NEON’s films in the collection, Saint Omer had previously not received a physical media release in the US — only streaming and digital media — and any francophile or cinephile who admires world cinema will undoubtedly want to have this on their shelf.

The Criterion Collection edition of Saint Omer is now available.